The place would Manchester United be with out Cristiano Ronaldo? That query has been posed nearly because the day the 37-year-old scored twice on his second Premier League debut for the membership throughout a 4-1 win in opposition to Newcastle at Previous Trafford final September. This adopted his switch from Juventus, for an preliminary €15 million, which noticed him return to United 12 years after leaving in a then-world-record £80 million switch to Actual Madrid.
As United put together to drag down the curtain on their worst season in additional than 30 years with a visit to Crystal Palace on Sunday — a season that has seen one supervisor (Ole Gunnar Solskjaer) fired and interim boss Ralf Rangnick develop into statistically the membership’s worst supervisor since Sir Alex Ferguson retired in 2013 — Ronaldo will finish the marketing campaign because the staff’s main objective scorer and maybe the one participant who has produced memorable moments for the precise causes throughout 2021-22.
In a season blighted by humiliating defeats, early cup exits, and dismal performances by many United gamers, Ronaldo’s double in opposition to Newcastle, essential late objectives within the Champions League in opposition to Villarreal and Atalanta (twice), and hat tips in opposition to Tottenham and Norwich have at the least highlighted why the membership signed him from Juventus final August.
However there’s a flip aspect to Ronaldo that has legitimately been cited by his detractors. His presence within the staff, the argument goes, makes United too predictable, denies the likes of Jadon Sancho and Marcus Rashford the liberty to play to their strengths within the remaining third and, at 37, he merely doesn’t have the legs to press opposition defenders and play the essential position of being his staff’s first line of defence. As a consequence, United concede an excessive amount of area and possession to opponents and are due to this fact extra weak to being attacked — 56 objectives conceded in 37 league video games underlines that idea.
All the above are legitimate observations. A 12 months after ending second within the Premier League with 73 objectives scored, United at the moment are bracing themselves for a final-day battle with West Ham for the doubtful distinction of ending sixth, and avoiding a spot in subsequent season’s Europa Convention League, having thus far netted simply 57 objectives this season — solely eight greater than their all-time lowest return of 49 objectives in a full marketing campaign.
However are United actually enduring one in all their worst seasons in dwelling reminiscence as a result of they introduced Cristiano Ronaldo again, or has the Portugal captain really saved them from an excellent worse marketing campaign just by scoring the objectives to maintain them excessive sufficient within the desk to nonetheless have an opportunity of qualifying for the Europa League?
Statistically at the least, Ronaldo has greater than justified his presence within the staff and his numbers definitely don’t level to him being an issue that United can do with out.
He has scored 18 Premier League objectives in 30 appearances and registered three assists, however with an xG of 17.59 and xA of two.04, Ronaldo has outperformed each metrics. Some would possibly argue that he has completed that on the expense of these round him, however different information reductions that. Ronaldo has a 50% success price in tackling, higher than all of his fellow forwards aside from Anthony Elanga, with Rashford (29.4%), Sancho (28.6), and Edinson Cavani (10) properly adrift of Ronaldo’s numbers. Elanga additionally has a price of fifty%.
By way of ball recoveries, solely Sancho (112) has a greater price among the many forwards than Ronaldo, who has registered 52. Elanga (49), Rashford (44), and Cavani (22) all have fewer than Ronaldo, albeit from fewer minutes on the pitch.
Gab and Juls debate whether or not Frenkie de Jong might reunite with Erik ten Hag at Man United.
Ronaldo was clearly not signed by United to win the ball again — he was recruited to offer the staff a dependable objective scorer who might make the distinction within the penalty field — however his work price off the ball is a big problem in that he cannot be anticipated to walk round whereas others do the work. However, his numbers are nonetheless higher than most of his fellow forwards.
His statistics when out of possession could possibly be higher, however he’s clearly not abandoning these obligations in favour of saving himself for the moments when he can put the ball within the internet. But when he was signed to be United’s focus and confirmed objective scorer, how has he measured up in opposition to the Premier League’s greatest? The reality is that he has completed properly and out-performed the vast majority of his rivals for the Golden Boot.
Solely Mohamed Salah (22) and Heung-Min Son (21) have scored extra Premier League objectives than Ronaldo this season. He’s unlikely to prime the charts, but when he scores twice in opposition to Palace, it could be a formidable achievement to interrupt the 20-goal barrier at 37 whereas taking part in within the worst United staff of the Premier League period.
Salah’s total numbers are testomony to the Liverpool ahead’s standing as one of many world’s prime forwards, with the Egypt worldwide additionally registering 13 assists, from an xA of simply 7.33. By way of xG, although, Salah is barely under-performing at 23.44.
Tottenham ahead Son, with 21 objectives and seven assists, is having fun with a outstanding season by considerably outperforming his xG (14.22) and xA (5.44). Spurs teammate Harry Kane, with 16 objectives and eight assists, is underperforming his xG (19.28) however outperforming his xA (5.07).
If United had been informed, when he signed, that Ronaldo would outscore Kane and outperform his personal xG and xA, the membership would have anticipated to be on track for a profitable season and maybe win a primary trophy since 2017. However sadly for United, whereas Ronaldo has delivered, the vast majority of his teammates have not.
So the place would United be with out Ronaldo? They don’t seem to be in an amazing place with him, however it could be a lot worse with out him.